Hi Judith

So far as I know, my McDOUGALLs came from Islay, only to Upper Canada which became Ontario in the 1800's. No mention of coming through New York.

No connection to a Catherine McEACHRON anywhere. 

Toni Sinclair is the best SINCLAIR connection here. She has them married to many from Islay.

I have one direct email for her

"Toni Sinclair" <tonisinclair@...>

beyond this Isaly list.

Good luck,

Malcolm